← sources

Follow-up to my 3-test moat score: you said check margins and cash flow. TSMC is where that gets hard.

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-10-26 13:38ingested 2026-10-27 02:40

retained text

Last week I posted a simple 3-test moat score and tried it on ASML. Best pushback I got: if the moat is real it should show up in margins, and you should look at cash flow next to the margin because margins can hold while cash drops. Fair enough, so I'm adding both as a sanity check.



**Tried it on TSMC (8.5 / 9.0 / 9.5 on my three tests).**



Margins are fine, it keeps almost 60 cents of every revenue dollar after the cost of making the chips. Nvidia (\~19%) and Apple (\~17%) are its biggest customers in 2025 and both need TSMC way more than TSMC needs either of them.



Cash flow is where it gets messy. They plan $50B+ of capex in 2026, and someone in the last thread pointed out FCF fell about 45% in 2023 while sales barely moved, then came back above where it was. So it was the building spree, not customers squeezing them on price. To me those are really different signals, but a simple cash flow check would treat them the same.



Two things I can't figure out:

1. Is spending at that scale part of the moat (nobody else can keep up) or just a cost that eats what the moat earns?

2. If you folded cash flow into the score, how would you do it without punishing companies for building ahead of demand?



Not about the stock or valuation, just how durable the position is.

document fetched 2026-10-27 00:45 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xfx29a/followup_to_my_3test_moat_score_you_said_check