Are people lobotomized? Why would anyone hand Zuckerberg the keys to their entire life with Muse?
retained text
Genuine question, not just ragebait. For anyone who missed it: Meta announced Muse on 8 September 2026, a personal AI agent that sends emails, books travel, opens a browser, fills forms, negotiates and checks out on the user's behalf. It's designed to access a person's apps across categories like email, calendar, payments, health, shopping and the smart home. And it can remember information from previous conversations and use it to make suggestions without being prompted. So: your inbox, your calendar, your payments, your health data*, y*our home. All of it, in one place. Run by Meta. Let's recap the company we're talking about: * **Cambridge Analytica (2018):** data from tens of millions of users harvested through a "personality quiz" and used for political targeting. Meta knew about it for years before it went public. * **The $5 billion FTC fine (2019):** the largest privacy penalty in FTC history at the time, for violating a consent decree Meta had already signed in 2012 promising to protect user privacy. They broke the promise they made after breaking the first promise. * **Onavo:** Meta marketed a "privacy" VPN app and used it to monitor what other apps people were using. * **The emotional contagion experiment (2014):** they deliberately manipulated hundreds of thousands of users' feeds to see if they could change their mood. Without telling them. * **WhatsApp:** bought with promises it would stay independent and private, then pushed users into sharing data with the rest of Meta. * And the infamous early Zuckerberg chat logs mocking people for trusting him with their personal data. He was 19, sure. But his company's behavior for the next 20 years didn't exactly prove that version of him wrong. Now, Meta's pitch for Muse is "trust us, it's private." Meta states directly that Muse does not share a person's conversations or the data in their VM with Meta's ad systems. Cool. Meta has also stated a lot of things in the past. Here's the part that should end the discussion: WIRED reported that Meta acknowledges Muse Secure VM is not technically inaccessible to Meta, even though company policy bars Meta from accessing users' Muse data. Read that again. The protection isn't technical. It's a policy. A policy Meta wrote, Meta enforces, and Meta can change. The encryption? Meta said it plans to introduce an encrypted version of the service later this year. So they launched first and will lock it down later. Maybe. Even the training opt-out is opt-out. Default is: your life feeds their models. And let's be clear about the incentive. The company is also investing heavily in AI infrastructure, with projected spending of more than $130 billion this year. Meta said it expects most people to stay on the free tier. A $130B bet, given away for free, by an advertising company. You are not the customer. You never were. I'm not anti-AI agents. The tech is genuinely useful. But an agent that reads your email, spends your money, and sees your health records is the single most intimate piece of software you'll ever use. Of all the companies on earth, Meta is the one that has spent two decades proving it should *not* be trusted with exactly that. So seriously: what am I missing? Why are people signing up?
document fetched 2026-10-04 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/AI_Agents/comments/1wwrcb3/are_people_lobotomized_why_would_anyone_hand