← sources

Even taken a job offer where not everyone wanted you there?

source: reddit (reddit:cscareerquestions)published 2026-10-19 20:57ingested 2026-10-20 02:36

retained text

I’m in an odd place with this job offer I got recently. I'm a SWE at company A which is a slow moving but stable non-tech company. Pay is not super competitive but WLB is great and my coworkers are very kind and chill. I recently got an offer from company B—a small startup that is offering me almost the same salary to do much more work, but the work is far more interesting and I do think the company is poised to do very well in the future and it is already profitable. 

My would-be boss at company B is awesome. I haven’t even worked with him yet but I’ve already learned from him just throughout the interview process itself. I think he’d be a great mentor and I can see myself growing a lot as an engineer by working here.

BUT. The role I was offered is not exactly what I applied for—the job posting was for a better paid, higher level role, but I was told that I did not perform well in the interviews. Some people were very skeptical about my ability to succeed at the company, but my would-be-manager fought hard for me, and so the compromise was bringing me in at a lower level and essentially giving me 6 months to prove myself before they promote me to what I would consider a more “expected” level given my YOE. 

I have no idea what to make of this. On one hand, all new hires are obviously under a lot of scrutiny during their first few months at a new company. And yet, it seems like a pretty stressful and precarious position to be in. I’m really inclined to accept the offer and do everything I can to prove them wrong, because if I do good work, since my would-be-manager is already fighting hard for me before I’ve even accepted the position, I really think he’d support me and advocate for a promotion. 

I’ve got a total of 3 years of industry experience and I still feel incredibly green most of the time, so can someone tell me if I’m being naive? Am I setting myself up for failure by accepting an offer than will put me under a lot of pressure to perform from day 1? Have any of you been in a situation like this and come out stronger, more knowledgable, and wealthier (lol) on the other side? Thanks.

document fetched 2026-10-20 00:23 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/1xa8uzq/even_taken_a_job_offer_where_not_everyone_wanted