Fast Ds Query: what is the government psychology here?
retained text
Why create unnecessary fear? 1) Employees who get RSU's, the taxes are already deducted even before you get the Rsu credited. So if you missed declaring in initial years (even though you have paid the tax on time), please pay 1 lakh to us otherwise there will be BMA on you? 2) Small dividend income, which if coming from USA gets already taxed at 25% by the foreign authority. Under Dtaa this would be rebate, and we have to pay 30% tax. So for this 5% tax difference whenever you missed paying, pay as much penalties as you can? Around 60% on the 5% difference or worse 60% on whatever got credited in your account, forget dtaa If the government has started getting this information, why not just highlight it from next time, also this time around, nudging everyone just to fill itr correctly. Ex: We see dividend, file schedule fsi. Ex: We see perquiste/rsu, file schedule FA. Fill AIS with this information already so no one misses. And in future you missed or make a mistake in disclosure, there would be a penalty. My thought is if some one missed 10k 15k INR here and there in filing taxes it should be okay, should be corrected via nudge, rather than penalising or threatening BMA on it. Given filing taxes in not that simple(thanks to AI it becomes slighlty easier in this and future years). We did not had AI in 2021-2023 to be this much perfect in filing the ITR. P:S did not use ai, there might be some grammatical errors.
document fetched 2026-09-28 00:42 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1wrfub1/fast_ds_query_what_is_the_government_psychology