← sources

Meta's Muse will be a complete flop. Tell me I'm wrong.

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-10-28 02:59ingested 2026-10-29 02:43

retained text

There has been a ton of buzz about Muse since it's release at the beginning of September.

I seem be the only person working from 1st principles to determine if there will actually be demand for the product. I can find hardly any discussion about this.

I have tested Muse repeatedly to see how it performs, here is what I've done:

1. Booking a restaurant reservation
2. Booking a flight
3. Booking a hotel
4. Shopping for clothes and shoes
5. Giving Muse access to my Walmart+ account to buy groceries for me.

On the last one, I actually ran a test where I wrote a grocery list and handed it to Muse, while simultaneously using Walmart+ to manually to do the shopping. The result was that it took Muse 7mins longer than me doing it manually.

While performing this test I realized that Walmart has their own Ai assistant named Sparky. I pasted the same list into Sparky and it pulled up every item in the chat with the quantity toggle button linked in. Ultimately, Sparky was way faster than me, and probably 10x faster than Muse.

Which leads me to my main conclusion. I think that consumer Ai assistants will fail in favour of individual businesses embedding Ai directly into their customer experiences, as Walmart has.

I also tested booking a hotel on Muse vs Google Ai mode. Google Ai mode was so much faster and easier it was shocking. Embedding Ai into the pre-existing workflow (looking for a hotel on google) supercharged the experience and makes it easier than I can even imagine.

It's a similar situation with shopping. Using the amazon Ai "Rufus" was so much easier to find a specific type of shoes I wanted. Muse was way slower and couldn't find what I was looking for. I did this using the exact same prompts for Muse and Rufus.

My point is, I am having so much trouble reconciling all this hype for Muse. It seems like people are caught up in the moment and focusing on what can be built rather than what there is demand for.

I think the average person will not get value from using Muse in anyway that they don't get value from other Ai models. The angle with Muse is that it plugs into all your data/apps and executes your online activities for you...

I believe this is going after a very slim margin of value and that Ai will decentralize into each individual business, being deployed to serve their customers in a far better way than 1 broad consumer Ai assistant ever could.

I think the creation of Muse is motivated by greed and the desire to revolutionize the world with a new technology - not grounded in solving real problems and providing value to individual customers.

PLEASE tell me how I could be wrong.

Follow up post: [https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xhw9mi/meta\_muses\_fatal\_flaw\_nobody\_can\_see/](https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xhw9mi/meta_muses_fatal_flaw_nobody_can_see/)

document fetched 2026-10-29 00:47 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xhcwoa/metas_muse_will_be_a_complete_flop_tell_me_im