← sources

AI is not necessarily progress, it all depends on the outcome

source: reddit (reddit:singularity)published 2026-10-20 18:30ingested 2026-10-21 02:38

retained text

The way most people define "progress" is increases in standard of living across the majority of people. Or the majority of people are happier. If progress means anything it should mean, the majority of people are happier. 

And that's why it's not actually fair at this point in history to say AI is "progress". Because AI might not make the majority of people happier. If AI causes WW3 for example or causes a mass casualty event, or bio T, then it was pretty clear that was not actually progress. If AI just causes a dystopian future and the majority of people to be unhappy while a small number of people are obscenely rich, then it was not actually progress. There are so many scenarios where AI might not be progress. In fact, AI has been proposed as one of the possible "Great Filters", the reason why we don't see any sign of intelligent life anywhere in the universe despite the universe being billions of years old. 

People who are anti-AI get referred to as "Luddites" because they're "against progress". The problem is no one really knows if AI will result in progress or not right now, it could very well not. We'll only know in retrospect whether AI was good for society or not. That's why being anti-AI does not make someone a "luddite". 

document fetched 2026-10-21 00:29 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/1xb04oi/ai_is_not_necessarily_progress_it_all_depends_on