← sources

Repeat buyer stalks my shop, buys quickly & uses discount, now nobody else ever sees my new stuff

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-11-08 17:23ingested 2026-11-09 02:35

retained text

Let me preface by saying I know this is my fault.  I have a repeat customer who had purchased 7 of my handmade pendants priced at $90 + and to show good will, I decided to give her a 15% off discount code - with NO expiration date!  I know - what was I thinking!  She's up to 30 orders.  If I raise my prices, they would be too expensive and I'd lose customers on the listings this repeat buyer doesn't buy.

She had messaged me just one time saying she loves my stuff and thank you for the generous offer.  But she's left no reviews (I can deal with that, what can you do)  She stalks my shop now, favoriting other of my shop items even when she's favorited them already, and I realize it's her way of saying she's waiting for something new from me and she's eager to make another purchase.    Because when she favorites and I list something new, she's right there.  And the thing is, while I know the style of pendants she likes, sometimes she doesn't purchase listings and if I raise prices, I'm left with extra-expensive listings that I overpriced, trying to compensate for her using her discount and buying.  I've really messed myself up here.  I literally cannot list any pendants that have really good, beautiful, high quality stones.  Nobody else will get a chance at those pendants because she's right there!  She'll by multiples of things!

On one hand, I'm appreciative because I do like to reward repeat customers, especially ones who purchase 7 expensive pendants.  But now that she has her 15% off eternal discount code, I'm now wondering if I'm ever going to be able to list new items comfortably in the hopes that NEW customers will see my good listings (with really nice stones that I know would sell at full price to other customers).  I've shot myself in the foot because I'm now finding myself making pendants with less-than-favorite stones in the hopes that she will buy them instead.  Meanwhile my really nice stones that I've been dying to work with and list just sit there because I don't want her to come in and swoop them up, leaving nobody else a chance to even see it!

It's making me lose excitement for creating because as soon as I list a pendant with a gorgeous stone, I know she will be right there waiting to claim it for 15% off.  I have a decent Instagram following but that place has gone downhill and I hardly get engagement and therefore cannot sell these beauties on Instagram quickly enough.

Is there anything I could tell this repeat buyer?  I know that I should honor my offer yet I genuinely did not realize the impact of a forever 15% off code given to someone who doesn't seem to want to stop (helped out by the discount code!! Ahhhh, lol! ) I'm even considering lying (!) and saying that Etsy has a built in limit for customers' discount code use that I didn't know of.  I'm desperate so I'm thinking of anything right now just to get rid of this cross I have to bear.  I want to make my jewelry with excitement again.

EDITED TO ADD - I've run a reversed image search and none of the items have come up elsewhere.  I do think she just likes jewelry in general.  And again, please know that I am very happy that she loves my work and that I am appreciative of her!  I just wish I didn't give her a a no-expiration-date discount code. I'm mulling over all of your responses, thank you!!!!  I'll update soon!

document fetched 2026-11-09 00:24 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xr3qsx/repeat_buyer_stalks_my_shop_buys_quickly_uses