First-time founder: am I getting screwed by giving this co-founder a chance? I will not promote
retained text
First-time non-technical founder here. I have a marketplace startup with a working web MVP, real traction from viral content, and we're starting a pre-seed raise. My technical co-founder brought in his friend, a senior mobile engineer, as CTO. The proposed split was 60/20/20, but nothing is signed. The situation: • He's been on the team for about a month, and I haven't seen any work from him yet. I've only spent about 8 days with him in person. • He flew out to the US to "help raise" with us, but he's only staying a week. • It's been a lot of talk about strategy and how much he brings. He's talked to one contact so far, while I've been in constant outreach. • He presents himself as having run a 500K-user app with millions in revenue. In reality he's a freelancer on that company's team, not the person running it. • My honest impression is that he's more excited about the title and telling friends and family than about the work. • He says he can build the full app in about a month. • When I said I wanted to see work before long-term decisions, he took it badly. He said that if I just want execution, I need an employee, not a partner. • There's been some friction, including personal remarks, and I don't trust him yet. • He's my co-founder's friend, so cutting him loose could strain that relationship too. My plan to give him a fair shot: • A 30–60 day trial before any equity is granted • Written deliverables: the full app by day 30 (his own estimate), then new features and investor intros by day 60 • If he delivers, 15% with 4-year vesting and a 1-year cliff • If not, he becomes a contractor or we part ways My main question: am I getting screwed over by trying to give him a chance? Also: 1. Is a trial before equity reasonable, or will it push away a good co-founder? 2. Is 15% fair for a CTO joining at this stage? 3. How do you judge a technical co-founder's work when you're not technical? 4. How do you verify a co-founder's claimed experience (references, code walkthrough, etc.)?
document fetched 2026-11-18 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/startups/comments/1xynsy2/firsttime_founder_am_i_getting_screwed_by_giving