5 years of making games, 0 finished. I want to break the cycle.
retained text
First of all, I want to state that this post is not written by AI, it is written by me personally in \~30 minutes. Secondly, English is not my native language so some of the phrasing may look weird, but I tried my best to explain my thoughts in a clear and structured way. I've been messing around with game development and Godot for around 5 years now. In that time I've probably started more projects than I can remember. Some of them got pretty far, some were basically just prototypes, but they all eventually ended the same way - abandoned when I got interested in building something else. I'm a software engineer full-time, although in a completely different field, so game dev has always been something I do after work. And I realized that the part I enjoy the most is actually ***building systems***. Movement, procedural stuff, tools, networking, weird mechanics, etc. The problem is that once those interesting technical problems were solved and the project reached the "okay, now actually make this into a game" phase... my brain was already looking for the next interesting thing to build. So after \~5 years of doing this, I have a graveyard of unfinished games and prototypes and not a single properly released game. Recently that changed a bit. I started working on a cool turn-based game in a small team of 3 people (1 designer, 1 storyteller and me). For the first time I'm not responsible for literally every part of a game, and having other people depending on what I build has made me approach development very differently. And weirdly enough, working seriously on one game made me want to go back and actually **finish some of the projects I abandoned**. I went through some of my older projects and picked one that I think is actually worth finishing. Not turning it into another huge multi-year project, but taking what is already there, polishing it, giving it a proper beginning and end, and actually **releasing something for once**. My current goal is to get it to a state where I can put out a proper playable demo and see what people think. Almost all of my "unfinished" games have multiplayer in their design, so this one as well but multiplayer is not something I can support in a free game. I am indie dev who has so far earned 0$ from games so the only way to support multiplayer in this game is for the game either to be paid upfront or a Free game with a paid pass (something similar to TrackMania?) But this also got me wondering how people approach this in 2026. Is [Itch.io](http://Itch.io) still a good place for releasing free games/demos and getting some actual players, or are there better options nowadays? What is the conversion rate of your demo players on [Itch.io](http://Itch.io) to real wishlist or even purchases of the game on Steam? How important are trailers for something like this? Do you make a proper trailer before releasing even a free demo, or is a short gameplay video/GIF and a decent store page enough? Also, should you release a demo on [Itch.io](http://Itch.io) without having a steam page up? Can I just release and see how it goes and then depending on success decide if I want to release the game on Steam or the multiplayer cost will unjustifiable? I'm also curious about **when you consider a demo "ready"**. Do you try to make it feel almost like a tiny finished game, or is it acceptable for it to be a bit rough (Graphics, UI) as long as the core gameplay is there? And probably the biggest question for people who have been in the same situation as me: **What helped you finally stop developing and actually press the release button?**
document fetched 2026-09-22 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wm911x/5_years_of_making_games_0_finished_i_want_to