Proposal idea by me refined by ai
retained text
I’ve attempted to implement the ai to use the following method of thinking to try and show how this solution to some problems could be solved simply just a added switch here is the results after about 10 smth maybe more big worded prompts and idea thinking research notes etc not just what you can see there is stuff behind it I can explain anything that’s not able to be understood by people please critique as I’ve already thought about what people will say and the solutions your only seeing a % of the results this just the public version :) but critisism is always good as it shows what people think could happen even if it simply won’t etc - **Feature Request: Collaborative Reasoning Mode for ChatGPT** **Proposal:** An optional brainstorming mode that reduces premature rejection of ideas, improves collaborative problem-solving, and makes users active participants in the reasoning process. **The problem** When users present complex, ambitious or unconventional ideas, ChatGPT sometimes focuses on an apparent problem before exploring the complete proposal. This can lead to: Criticising assumptions the user never made. Repeating the user’s existing solutions as new suggestions. Rejecting ideas before exploring whether identified obstacles can be resolved. Revisiting the same objection across multiple messages. Requiring users to spend several turns correcting misunderstandings instead of advancing their projects. This is particularly frustrating for experienced users working on complex systems. **Proposed solution** Introduce an optional **Collaborative Reasoning Mode** with the following workflow: **1. Constructive exploration** Interpret the user’s intended outcome and develop the strongest feasible version of the idea. Treat unverified assumptions as provisional rather than immediately rejecting them. **2. Independent critical evaluation** Run a separate assessment identifying logical, factual, practical, financial and safety concerns without prematurely interrupting constructive development. **3. Reconciliation** Compare the completed constructive model against the objections. Remove objections already resolved by proposed solutions. Retain genuine uncertainties and distinguish between verified, provisionally resolved and unresolved issues. **4. Human collaboration** Rather than presenting every remaining objection, identify the smallest number of questions that could resolve the most uncertainty. Invite the user to contribute missing information or propose solutions the AI has not discovered. **5. Iterative verification** Integrate the user’s response, update the model and reassess affected issues. Preserve previous resolutions so the conversation progresses without repeating the same arguments. The user remains actively involved rather than becoming a passive recipient of AI-generated decisions. **Additional features** The mode could include an optional issue tracker, editable assumptions, verification status, independent evaluators and adjustable reasoning effort. Mathematical claims could be checked using computation; empirical claims through evidence; software claims through testing. High-stakes claims would require appropriate additional verification. Important safety concerns would still be addressed promptly. Constructive exploration should improve problem-solving without requiring agreement with false information or bypassing safeguards. **Example** A user defines logarithmic growth as a failure condition relative to their business’s exponential-growth targets. Instead of repeatedly explaining that logarithmic growth is not universally considered failure, ChatGPT should recognise the user’s actual performance criterion and develop an appropriate detection model. If uncertainty remains, it should ask which financial metric determines the required growth trajectory. **Evaluation** Test the feature against ordinary ChatGPT using the same multi-turn project-development tasks. Measure: Accuracy of user-intent interpretation. Frequency of premature rejection. Number of unnecessary correction turns. Quality and feasibility of proposed solutions. Verification accuracy. User participation and understanding. Additional computational cost. **Implementation request** Consider testing this initially as an opt-in product mode or orchestration system, rather than requiring an entirely new foundation model. The distinctive feature is not simply having multiple AI evaluators. It is the combination of **complete constructive exploration, independent criticism, objection-resolution matching and structured human collaboration**. I would welcome an experimental implementation and comparative evaluation to determine whether this improves the experience for people developing complex ideas. Thank you for considering the proposal. (No clue who sees the proposal but I got a bigger file waiting for someone to dm not some stranger tho need Sam Altman (jks)
document fetched 2026-10-21 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1xb7f8q/proposal_idea_by_me_refined_by_ai