← sources

Nextdoor at $330K vs a Staff role at a Series C startup for $200K?

source: reddit (reddit:cscareerquestions)published 2026-10-29 18:39ingested 2026-10-30 02:36

retained text

I recently had to decide between staying at Nextdoor and joining a startup headed for a Series C as a Staff Engineer. I did the math on it, and I’m sharing it because it changed how I think about startup equity.

**On paper:**

* Nextdoor: $230k base + $100K/yr in RSUs
* Series B: $200k base + 12,000 options (about 0.025% of the company)

**The RSUs were worth less than they looked.** My grant only covered 2 years, and the stock was falling. At −30%/yr, 4 years of RSUs pay about $212K, not $400K. Staying was still about $330K ahead in cash over 4 years, or more if the stock held flat.

**The options were worth less than they sounded.** Even if the Series C comes in at a $1B valuation, a strike around a third of the last round’s price leaves my vested options at roughly $50K to $90K by year 4. To make up $330K, the company would need to exit at around $5B.

So the decision isn't necessarily about money. It was about whether a higher title working on foundational architecture and being more than a cog were worth $300K+ to me with a small chance at a big exit. Things like age, net worth, expenses, and risk tolerance all play a factor in my specific decision.

What I’d check before taking a startup offer over a public company:

1. Value RSUs at a realistic future price, and check when the grant ends.
2. Work out the exit valuation your options need to match staying. That number is usually a lot higher than people expect.
3. Ask for the fully diluted share count, or you can’t do step 2.
4. Budget as if the options are worth $0.
5. Put a dollar value on the scope separately, and be honest about whether you’ll actually use it.

How do you all value startup equity when you’re comparing offers? Do you count it at zero or do you give it some value?

document fetched 2026-10-30 00:23 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/1xisbhb/nextdoor_at_330k_vs_a_staff_role_at_a_series_c