← sources

Etsy marked customer message as spam

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-09-29 04:26ingested 2026-09-30 02:39

retained text

Weird situation.  I did a custom order for a lady.  Yesterday I completed the order and made a custom listing for her so she could get it at her leisure.  She sent me a message today telling me it'll be a day or two before she purchases it etc etc and I'm fine with that.  We have a long message thread going on in etsy because she changed things here and there with the order/no big deal.  

So ANYWAY, ......today she sends me a message like "oh by the way......would it be cheaper for me if I venmo'd you directly?  She mentioned it would be cheaper for her (no tax) and me (no fees) yadda yadda.  It was just a quick message basically saying that stuff.    
  
I was going to reply with the standard No Thanks/gotta keep it on Etsy yadda yadda......but there is no longer a "reply" box in the message stream.  I got to looking at I guess it's because ETSY marked the message as SPAM so I can SEE it in my spam folder but can't respond.

I can mark it as NOT SPAM and that will move it back to my inbox and I can reply.  However..................I'm almost hesitant to do that because I don't wanna get caught up in some AI bot hell where they mistakenly pause or suspend my shop.  I'm probably being paranoid but hey........I don't wanna take any chances so thought I'd toss it out here and ask what most would do.

NORMALLY I'd just leave it in spam and forget about it but I feel bad because she's been messaging me all along and this is a custom order she seems to really be excited about getting for her project.  So I feel rude not answering her.

WWYD?  I can NOT answer and just wait for her to either purchase it or not

OR I can mark the message as NOT spam and go ahead and answer her and let her know off site payments are NOT an option and why

document fetched 2026-09-30 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wt0jk2/etsy_marked_customer_message_as_spam