Before AI Gobbles Up Everyone's Jobs, Can We Talk About Those Jobs That Are Mission Critical?
retained text
Before we let AI loose gobbling up everyone's jobs, perhaps we should examine some of the professions where people's lives depend on making the right decisions at the right time. I'm not talking about solving complex mathematical equations or theorizing on some neuroscience discovery. I'm talking about ordinary people doing extraordinary things as part of their everyday jobs. Take our firefighters, for example. During bushfire season, they're dealing with changing winds, unpredictable fire behaviour, deciding where to put firebreaks, where to deploy water-bombing aircraft and how to get their crews safely into and out of dangerous situations. These decisions are often made under enormous pressure, with very little time to spare. Get it wrong, and a disaster response could become an even bigger disaster in the making. But here's the thing. For experienced firefighters, this is part of their job. We don't go around describing them as superintelligent, although I would certainly describe their judgement, courage and bravery as extraordinary. They draw on years of experience, an understanding of their environment and the ability to recognise when circumstances are changing. And importantly, they know that sometimes a decision made five minutes too late is no decision at all. So are we in danger of throwing the baby out with the bathwater? We're getting terribly excited about what AI can do, but are we paying enough attention to what humans already do? What about wisdom, experience, intuition, judgement and the courage to act when the consequences are enormous? How are we accounting for those qualities when we talk about replacing people with autonomous machines? I'm not opposed to AI. Quite the contrary. I think it has enormous potential to assist in these situations, particularly with analysing information, predicting changing conditions and supporting the people making critical decisions. But helping an experienced professional and replacing that professional's judgement are two very different things. If full autonomy is where we're heading, then surely we need convincing evidence that AI can handle these situations under real-world pressure. Not just produce the right answer, but recognise the context, understand the urgency, adapt to changing circumstances and make the right decision at the right time. Because when lives are at stake, being really knowledgeable is all very well, but what happens when the knowledge isn't applied appropriately or without context? I'd be genuinely interested in hearing people's thoughts, particularly how these capabilities are being tested. Surely this is fundamental due diligence before we start handing over responsibilities that carry real-life consequences or risk real people’s lives. Because it scares the bejesus out of me if this hasn’t been thought through by the parentals of AI.
document fetched 2026-11-01 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/artificial/comments/1xkbdkv/before_ai_gobbles_up_everyones_jobs_can_we_talk