← sources

What growth rate do we actually need to "grow out of" $40 trillion in debt

source: reddit (reddit:economy)published 2026-09-28 16:46ingested 2026-09-29 02:43

retained text

Every post I've put up lately has generally gone towards the same place, I am a doomer and the comments can get dark. 

So let’s flip it, let’s look at it from the optimistic POV and see what the math actually shows. Bessent recently said we will grow our way out with 3% growth and some spending restraint. Trump says growth will take care of debt. I think about a third to half of the people here think it’s possible and I am fear mongering. So let’s assume they're right and see what it takes to work.

The math is simple, if the economy grows faster than the interest rate on the debt, the debt shrinks relative to the economy. If the interest rate is higher, the debt grows on its own. That's the whole equation and game it takes to work. 

Here's Bessent's case, and it's technically possible. 3% real growth plus roughly 3% inflation is 6% nominal growth. New Treasury debt costs about 5%. 6 beats 5, so for now using just these numbers, we're ahead. That is the part he's right about, and CFR ran the same numbers last week and agreed debt to GDP roughly levels off at 3%.

The catch, we also run about $800 billion a year in deficit before interest. With debt at 123% of GDP, covering that gap means growth has to beat the rate by about 2 points, not 1. So 6% nominal growth against 5% debt still loses ground, just slower. For his plan to work, the second half of the plan actually has to be executed by congress and president, the spending restraint has to cut that $800 billion new deficit spending roughly in half, and the 3% real growth has to show up every single year.

So it's a bet with two huge conditions. Number 1., 3% real growth sustained year after year. The US has averaged about 2% for 20 years. Q3 is tracking 5, which is great, but Q2 was 1.5, and the 5 is mostly $870 billion of AI data center construction borrowed at 8 to 10%. Number 2., real spending cuts. Bessent says he's waiting until after the midterms to move on these, and the President is pitching a $1.3 trillion payout to voters if his side wins. And any real meaningful cuts would have to come from congress, but with an active war, over $1 trillion DoD budget, a Social Security fund in desperate need of money, and all the other entitlements, where do you find $800 billion without raising revenue?

And to complicate matters more, the target keeps moving. Every point the long end climbs adds a point to the growth we need. The 30 year just hit 5.57, a new 52 week high, and the 10 year has gone from 4.9 to 5.26 as writing this in a week.

So here's my take, Bessent isn't lying. The math works on paper, but it needs 3% growth we haven't produced outside of this latest AI spending spike and requires spending cuts or new taxes that nobody has proposed yet, and it needs both of them to work and the bond market is not waiting for him.

If you're still in the "we'll be fine, it is going to work" camp, what am I missing?

https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/articles/u-economy-running-hot-stuck-172448875.html

document fetched 2026-09-29 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/economy/comments/1wsjtpc/what_growth_rate_do_we_actually_need_to_grow_out