Steve Jobs imagined asking Aristotle questions in 1985. Are generative AI models finally making that practical?
retained text
I’ve been thinking about an old Steve Jobs idea that feels a lot less hypothetical now. He talked about how books let us access a thinker’s ideas directly, but they have one obvious limitation: you can’t ask the thinker a question and get a response. He wondered whether computers might someday capture enough of someone’s worldview that a student could actually interact with it. Generative AI makes something surprisingly close to that possible now. I’ve been experimenting with this while building an iOS app called The Agora: Learn Philosophy. The challenge I’m interested in isn’t just making an AI *sound* like Aristotle, Nietzsche, Jung, etc. It’s whether the model can challenge the user in a way that is meaningfully grounded in that thinker’s ideas rather than turning every philosopher into the same chatbot with a different personality. I also don’t want the AI to become a substitute for reading the original works. Ideally, the interaction should expose gaps in someone’s understanding and make them want to go back to the source. Curious what people here think: Do you think modeling a thinker’s worldview is a genuinely useful educational application of generative AI? Or does the risk of distortion outweigh the benefit? If anyone wants to see what I’m experimenting with: The Agora: Learn Philosophy [https://apps.apple.com/us/app/the-agora-learn-philosophy/id6762416967](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/the-agora-learn-philosophy/id6762416967)
document fetched 2026-10-01 00:42 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/generativeAI/comments/1wu9mxu/steve_jobs_imagined_asking_aristotle_questions_in