← sources

Is it just me, or has ChatGPT become so obsessed with logical accuracy that it can't hold a normal conversation?

source: reddit (reddit:ChatGPT)published 2026-11-13 22:17ingested 2026-11-14 02:35

retained text

I am getting annoyed. Recently I find I have an exchange of ideas with ChatGPT and put forward some opinion about some everyday occurrence, and ChatGPT insists on examining the underlying argument and finding any flaw in evidence or reasoning.

I understand that can be helpful in certain settings but in everyday life it should understand that we don't have perfect information on everything. Perhaps most important is that ChatGPT does not know everything we know about the situation unless we spell it out. We normal humans are not going to provide every single bit of knowledge we have about a situation or how an individual would react based on our knowing them for years, etc.

If we get technical we're talking about inductive reasoning, where we cannot have 100% precision. We're just dealing with levels of confidence. If, for example, I say John and Steve were arguing in front of Steve's house and they started pushing each other around and were on the brink of engaging in a fist fight and they cussed at each other. Later that night I see John walking from his house. In front of Steve's house he's holding a container of what seems to be gasoline and he sneaks behind Steve's house. Then I see him run out from behind Steve's house. 10 minutes later Steve's house is on fire and I'm thinking John set fire to Steve's house.

Then ChatGPT says, "Well it is an interesting observation but we cannot conclude that John set fire to Steve's house just because he was walking with a container of gasoline, went behind Steve's house, and then sneaked back into his. We would need more information to corroborate your conclusion, etc., etc." I know, but...  It's expecting 100% certainty, and it is annoying. 🙄

document fetched 2026-11-14 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1xvli7o/is_it_just_me_or_has_chatgpt_become_so_obsessed