← sources

partner wants to go to 30% off for BFCM this year. last year we did 20% + $15 store credit and I can't tell if it worked

source: reddit (reddit:smallbusiness)published 2026-11-19 17:48ingested 2026-11-20 02:37

retained text

Small apparel brand, around $1.8M a year. Last BFCM we held at 20% off instead of going to 30%, and everyone who ordered got $15 store credit good Jan 2 to Jan 31.

BFCM weekend revenue came in about 6% under the year before. Margin was better, which was the point.

388 of 2,140 BFCM customers used the credit in January, so 18%. Their average January order was $71. The credit email only went out once  (Jan 2) and almost all the redemptions came in the first four days, so I'd guess a reminder would have helped, but I don't actually know that.

My business partner wants 30% this year and no credit. Their argument is that the 6% is real money and those January orders might have happened anyway. I can't prove they wouldn't have. We have to lock the offer this weekend.

How would you make this call? Is there any way to tell whether the credit actually cause those January orders?

document fetched 2026-11-20 00:29 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/1y0ftxo/partner_wants_to_go_to_30_off_for_bfcm_this_year