← sources

What would you do?

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-09-23 02:28ingested 2026-09-24 02:37

retained text

I sell labels / stickers that are waterproof and oil resistant.

I have a customer that placed a very small order a month ago, and just messaged me complaining that the item had become damaged and are asking for a replacement. 

I do not claim my labels are damage proof, and I do instruct people to be gentle with them and point out some of the ways in which they can be demanded (for example they are not stain proof either and this is made clear to the customer) 

They say the item hasn’t come into contact with water or oil (and that wouldn’t damage the label anyways). They sent a photo and it’s pretty clear that the label has been scratched or rubbed up against something and became damaged from use. 

There’s a lot of audacity in damaging your purchase and asking for a replacement, I feel like these people are generally not worth it as customers because they are the types that will always try to cheat the system how or always have an issue to get a refund or a discount.

Because this is such a small order, I will actually lose money if I send a replacement, it’s not a situation where I will even break even. Also the last time I sent a customer a replacement that they had very clearly damage themselves (and also used incorrectly and not according to instructions) they never bought anything ever again. 

But, I’m interested to hear what other sellers do with situations like these and why? Do you replace something like this as a sign of goodwill and hope that they actually become a repeat customer? Would you say no? Would you offer something in between like a discount or free item if they pay for shipping? 

document fetched 2026-09-24 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wntk0q/what_would_you_do