Home Depot vs Lowe’s: similar margins, very different use of capital (FY2025, from the 10-Ks)
retained text
**Scope note:** business comparison from the 10-K filings. No valuation, no buy/sell view. **Where they sit (FY2025)** \- Revenue: $164.7B vs $86.3B \- Operating income: $20.9B vs $10.2B \- Shareholders' equity at year end: $12.8B vs **−$9.9B** \- ROE: 145.5% vs not meaningful (negative equity) \- Return on invested capital (after-tax operating income ÷ average debt + leases + equity − cash): **22.1% vs 26.9%**, on $72.0B vs $28.7B **Where the gap comes from** Not margins: after-tax operating margin is 9.7% vs 9.0%. It's turnover. Lowe's turns $100 of capital into $300 of sales, Home Depot into $229. **What weakens this** One year doesn't settle it. Both returns fell a lot since FY2021 (Home Depot 43.0% → 22.1%, Lowe's 39.3% → 26.9%). Both also bought companies recently: Home Depot about $23B in FY2024–25 (SRS, GMS), Lowe's $10.1B in FY2025 (FBM, ADG). Part of that new capital hasn't had a full year to earn yet. **What I'll watch** Q3 results: Home Depot on Nov 17, Lowe's on Nov 18. Does operating income start catching up with the capital they just added? **Bottom line** ROE here mostly measures buybacks, not the business. Home Depot's profit barely moved in five years while its ROE went from over 2,000% to 145.5%, and Lowe's ROE can't even be calculated. When equity is this small or negative, I read the return on all the capital instead, and over five years, not one. On that measure Lowe's earns more today, and both are earning less than they did in FY2021. For retailers that buy back this much stock, do you still look at ROE at all, or only at return on total capital? Longer write-up with sources on my Substack: [https://substack.com/@inwoinvesting/note/p-220101232?r=98a7ts&utm\_medium=ios&utm\_source=notes-share-action](https://substack.com/@inwoinvesting/note/p-220101232?r=98a7ts&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action) No position in either.
document fetched 2026-10-24 10:45 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xdgafz/home_depot_vs_lowes_similar_margins_very